The sanitary work of destructive criticism

Jan 4, 2026

We cannot but be struck by the remarkable prevalence of systems of doctrine, by their loudness, their confusion, and their deleterious effect on conduct. In all these systems the most indulgent examination will find little evidence of really enterprising thought, but it will find a great deal of reconditioned lumber, at its best of a low order of reality and now used to justify the lazier, the uglier, and the baser inclinations of the human spirit. At no time in the history of the intellect has the sanitary work of destructive criticism been more needful.

Wilfred Trotter

I was reminded of this article today, thinking about how willing we are to defer to experts and how dismissive we are of thinkers.

How curious that tyranny often comes from the pursuit of safety.